heres a pic of the lugs on my alloys now
these were the lugs on my steelies
what does urs look like? u need the ones like the top pic
not sure what to do, 702L32 said its fine but then you said you had to get new rims
the dealerships are lazy and use the impact gun on everything including your precious alloy wheels. its okay for taking them off but NOT for putting the lugs back on. (always ask for hand tightening if u can). after awhile it takes a toll on the lug holes and fux them up. after initial torquing of the lugs and they seat, the hole should stay the same and not get bigger. if they are that means the lugs are going on too tight. always hand tighten alloy wheels and using a torque wrench is IDEAL